View Mobile Site

Ask the Expert

Signal Photos


The hours of Oscar: Broadcast begins at 5 p.m. Sunday night

Posted: February 25, 2011 6:00 a.m.
Updated: February 25, 2011 6:00 a.m.
Who will win the Academy Awards this Sunday night? Who will win the Academy Awards this Sunday night?
Who will win the Academy Awards this Sunday night?

On the day the Oscar nominations were announced, I made some quick guesses and toyed with the possibility that "True Grit" might sneak in. I've changed my mind, and now agree with the conventional wisdom that "The King's Speech" will be the year's best picture. Still, "True Grit" or "The Social Network" could pull off an upset. You might want to consider that in entering the $100,000 Outguess Ebert contest this year.

The contest is being co-sponsored by, an online art theater, with the Chicago Sun-Times, "Ebert Presents at the Movies" and Everyone who outguesses me gets a three-month subscription to MUBI worth $45, and those who get all 24 categories correct will split the $100K. That's even if I get them all right, which is very unlikely.
If I were still doing "If We Picked the Winners" with Siskel, my preference for best film would be "The Social Network." It was not only the best film of 2010, but one of those films that helps define a year. It became the presumed front-runner on the day it opened, but then it seemed to fade. Oscars often go to movies that open after Thanksgiving. It's called the Persistence of Memory Effect.

There's another factor. A lot of academy voters don't choose the "best" in some categories, but the "most advantageous for the movie industry." Hollywood churns out violent crap every weekend and then puts on a nice face by supporting a respectable picture at Oscar time. I mean that not as a criticism of "The King's Speech," which is a terrific film, but as an observation. A British historical drama about a brave man struggling to overcome a disability and lead his people into World War II looks better to the academy than a cutting-edge portrait of hyperactive nerds.

OK. I have 23 more categories to get through. A paragraph apiece:

Best Actor
Colin Firth for "The King's Speech." Jeff Bridges is unlikely to win the second year in a row, and although James Franco did a heroic job under his (shall we say) constraints in "127 Hours," Hollywood often gives extra points to U.K. nominees and loves British history.

Best Actress
In the way that such matters are decided by currents wafting in the air, Natalie Portman has emerged as the consensus choice. She is very good in "Black Swan." That's beside the point. Everyone is good in this category. But she gets to "act" the most, which to the academy often means "act out in emotional displays." She was required to do that by the logic of the role, which had Oscar written all over it.

Best Supporting Actor
Geoffrey Rush. Because it could be a "King's Speech" year. Christian Bale seems to have a good chance, but when a movie gets anointed, its aura shines on its other nominees, as if voters are thinking, "Well, if I voted for ‘King's Speech,' doesn't that mean I keep voting for it?"

Best Supporting Actress
That tendency won't carry over to this category, however, because while Helena Bonham Carter as the king's wife was splendid, as she almost always is, the role wasn't showy. The academy has a way in this category of anointing a plucky young newcomer, and the winner will be Hailee Steinfeld, who in fact played the lead in "True Grit," no matter what the academy thinks. Melissa Leo and Amy Adams will split support for "The Fighter."

Best Director
Well, here I'm more or less forced to choose Tom Hooper of "The King's Speech," because he won the Directors Guild Award, and you know the mantra: The DGA winner wins the Oscar 90 percent of the time. Contrarian speculation would be risky.

Best Original Screenplay
Again, "The King's Speech," by David Seidler. When a film becomes the chosen one, its glories trickle down, and I expect this to be a royal year. If I'm wrong, I'm very wrong. (The best screenplay, in terms of sheer writing, was Mike Leigh's "Another Year," which could easily be adapted more or less whole for the stage.)

Best Adapted Screenplay
Here "The Social Network" will win its one major Oscar, although deserving more. "Adaptation" often means "loosely inspired by," and Aaron Sorkin's brilliant dialogue and construction were wholly original (as were apparently many of his facts). You have to ask yourself what, precisely, the nominated "Toy Story 3" was adapting, apart from the continuing plight of the toys.

Best Foreign Language Film
Here we have an interesting situation because the voters in this category have to see all the nominees. That leads to victories by dark horses, like the wonderful Japanese corpse-preparation movie "Departures" a few years ago. This year, I've seen three of the five, but friends who have seen the Quebec film "Incendies" at festivals say it's great. If they're right, it's "Incendies."

Best Animated Feature
"Toy Story 3," don't you suppose?

Best Documentary Feature
What should win: "Restrepo," a year in the life of an outpost in Afghanistan. What will win: "Inside Job," about how Wall Street is run by crooks getting rich on our money.

Best Cinematography
Roger Deakins has been nominated eight times. This is the year he will win, for the magnificent look and feel of "True Grit."

Best Editing
"The Social Network" was all but brought to life through the skills of Angus Wall and Kirk Baxter, who took a complex group of interlocking plots, events and times, assembled them at breakneck speed, and made the sucker play.

Best Art Direction
Sometimes the art direction of a film just reaches out and rubs you by the chinny-chin-chin. Tim Burton is famous for the look of his films, and the work by Robert Stromberg and Karen O'Hara was magical in his "Alice in Wonderland."

Best Costume Design
Any good "Alice" starts with the costumes. Colleen Atwood dressed Wonderland.

Academy voters do not, I suspect, spend a lot of time thinking about this category, and often simply vote for the most makeup. That would indicate Rick Baker and Dave Elsey for "The Wolfman." But I have an instinct not many voters saw it, and here I predict Adrien Morot, for the way he aged Paul Giamatti in "Barney's Version." Warning: Baker has a good track record.

Best Original Score
The most effective score in foreground terms was by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, for "The Social Network." But I believe a "King's Speech" year will also sweep up this Oscar, for Alexandre Desplat.

Best Original Song
I would vote for "Coming Home," from "Country Strong." But in recent years this category has tended to be dominated by animation, and Disney/Pixar will take home the Oscar for "We Belong Together," the heartfelt dirge of forgotten playthings in "Toy Story 3."

Best Visual Effects
Continuing to apply my theory that in the "lesser" categories the winners tend to be the most visible in the most-seen films, I think this is where the sensational film "Inception" wins. It rolled up an entire city.

Best Sound Editing
"Inception," for its skill in negotiating dreamscapes and levels of reality. Not nominated was "The Social Network," which juggled all those rapid-fie conversations.

Best Sound Mixing
Also known as "Sound Design," this is the category that creates the space our ears sense around characters. I expect the winner to be "The Social Network," which created intricate conversations in challenging locations like a Silicon Valley club.

Best Animated Short
Teddy Newton's "Day and Night" played before "Toy Story 3," was original and inventive in the battle suggested by its title.

Best Documentary Short
"Killing in the Name," about a Muslim who visits and questions the sources of the terrorist ideology that inspired a suicide bomber to kill 27 people at his wedding.

Best Live Action Short Film
I haven't seen these. But I've looked at their trailers at, and on that basis I expect "Na Wewe" to win.

© 2011 THE EBERT CO.



Most Popular Articles

There are no articles at this time.
Commenting not available.
Commenting is not available.


Powered By
Morris Technology
Please wait ...