View Mobile Site

Ask the Expert

Signal Photos


Sleep wars have begun

Posted: June 22, 2012 1:55 a.m.
Updated: June 22, 2012 1:55 a.m.

It looks like the "sleep wars" have begun.

Several weeks ago, in a column on attachment parenting, I wrote "James J. McKenna, director of the Mother-Baby Sleep Laboratory at the University of Notre Dame, says that he has yet to find any benefit to parents and children sleeping together."

I arrived at that conclusion after reading an online Q/A in which he wrote "The truth is that there is no one outcome (good or bad) that can be associated with co-sleeping in the form of bed-sharing, but rather a range of outcomes (from potentially beneficial to dangerous and risky) depending on the overall circumstances within which the co-sleeping takes place."

In a response at, McKenna says he firmly believes co-sleeping is beneficial, as supported by his own and others' refereed published scientific research.

He has even written a blog titled "Cosleeping and Biological Imperatives: Why Human Babies Do Not and Should Not Sleep Alone."

McKenna lists a number of benefits to co-sleeping, including breastfeeding advantages, superior cognitive ability at age 6, and greater problem-solving independence during toddlerhood.

He also claims to have found young adults who bedshared as infants and young children were more satisfied with their bodies and had more secure gender identities.

Nonetheless, a 2002 study done by researchers at the University of California, Los Angeles, and published in the Journal of Developmental and Behavior Pediatrics found that by age 18, children who had slept with their parents as youngsters showed no advantage over children who had slept alone.

The factors looked at included social skills, drug and alcohol use, antisocial behavior, and overall psychological well-being. I'm reasonably certain that study was refereed, meaning it had to pass rigorous peer review in order to be published.

Dr. Alice Callahan, who writes a blog at has carried out an extensive review of the literature pertaining to methods of training infants to fall asleep on their own.

She concludes that sleep training results in reduced bedtime struggles, fewer night wakings, and longer sleep periods for both baby and parents.

Interestingly, these results are irrespective of the form of sleep training used, including letting babies cry themselves to sleep.

When one looks at the total body of research into infant and child sleep, the contention that co-sleeping or bed-sharing is superior to solo sleep seems impossible to objectively defend.

Family psychologist John Rosemond answers parents' questions on his web site at



Most Popular Articles

There are no articles at this time.
Commenting not available.
Commenting is not available.


Powered By
Morris Technology
Please wait ...